Words by Charlotte Vimeux PZ ’29
Graphic by Sophie Frankfurt PZ ’29
A highly consequential election is right around the corner, and both political parties are feeling the pressure. The stakes extend beyond Congressional control. A Republican victory would let Trump and his administration keep passing legislation through Congress. A Democratic win would dramatically change the relationship between Congress and the White House. These midterm elections are bound to shake things up.
Trump and his associates have tried to rally Republicans around midterm turnout, even promising a $5,000 dividend to every American adult if Republicans retain control of Congress. Meanwhile, Trump’s approval ratings remain low: an Ipsos poll from September found that 62% of Americans disapproved of his performance.
Yet Trump remains the Republican Party’s figurehead. His influence in the midterm primaries suggests the elections may be more about allegiance to Trump than the candidates, with 97% of Trump-endorsed candidates winning their primary. At the same time, Democrats face a difficult battle to regain control of Congress. To recapture the Senate, Democrats need to gain four seats while retaining the ones they already have. In the House, Democrats need to gain three seats to reach a majority, a harder feat this election cycle because Republicans have drawn congressional maps in states like Texas, Louisiana, Alabama, and more.
To better understand what voters, candidates, and the political parties are facing, I spoke with two Claremont politics professors: Claremont McKenna College’s George Thomas, who specializes in American constitutionalism, American political thought, constitutional law, and the Supreme Court, and Pitzer College’s Rachel Van-Sickle-Ward, who specializes in public policy, public law, gender, politics, and elections.
Outback: What do you think is fundamentally different about the 2026 midterm elections compared to previous midterms?
Vansickle-Ward: The midterms are… either going to be an endorsement or rebuke of this president that has amassed power in a pretty unique way and who has continued a movement and support, even being out of office for a full term.
Thomas: You know, I’m not sure if there really is anything fundamentally different about these elections. Midterms normally act as a referendum on the president, which is historically common when the president’s party controls Congress, and this election looks, to me, like it’s shaping up to be a referendum on the president. I mean, what do you think is different?
OB: To me, these elections seem far more polarized than in past terms.
Thomas: Ah yes, I see what you are saying. You might have people who are dissatisfied with the current state of things, but, you know, polarized enough that…what really drives them is their hate for the other party. It is interesting because dissatisfaction with a sitting president would normally lead more people to vote for the opposite party in Congress. Instead, party loyalty may outweigh the need for change.
While the national political environment shapes elections, voters aren’t choosing only between Republicans or Democrats. They are choosing specific candidates who, according to Thomas, play a big role in turnout, despite party loyalty.
Texas has traditionally been a Republican stronghold, so what about the current political climate has created an opening for Democrats this election?
VanSickle-Ward: I caution against viewing this race as evidence of a fundamental change in Texas politics. Texas has long been a conservative stronghold, but also an important battleground for issues that seem to mobilize Democratic voters. Texas, for example, is a “ground zero” for fights over reproductive rights. Conservative policies often emerge in Texas before they gain national attention. Elections rarely come down to particular candidates; they’re much more about fundamentals. These fundamentals include broader demographics and structural trends, not a candidate’s popularity. There have been countless times when Democrats have predicted Texas would go blue and yet still lost to the “fundamentals” despite the candidate. It’s dangerous to hope Texas will turn. Historically, a candidate can gain immense popularity but still struggle to overcome Texas’s long-established conservative tradition.
That distinction is important in the 2026 Senate election. James Talarico, the Democratic candidate, leads Republican candidate Ken Paxton by two points in the polls. The question remains whether this lead will hold.
Thomas offered a somewhat different perspective than VanSickle-Ward. While he acknowledged the importance of the broader political environment and Texas’ history with conservatism, he argued that candidate quality remains most important.
“Paxton is an awful candidate whom his constituents haven’t liked much. Conversely, Talarico is an excellent candidate. For all the polarization that exists in America, and it really does, candidates still matter,” Thomas said.
We’ve talked about the broader forces shaping this election, but there’s also been a noticeable shift happening within the Democratic Party itself. How significant is the rise of progressive or “insurgent” candidates in 2026, and what does it tell us about where the party is heading?
VanSickle-Ward: Successful insurgent campaigns are worth studying, but it’s risky to make a candidate the arbiter of what success looks like. Mamdani ran a really impressive campaign, and that is absolutely worth looking into, but New York voters aren’t the same as the general electorate. This isn’t to diminish the insurgent left’s obvious success; it’s a warning not to treat their wins as a foregone conclusion.
Thomas: What matters is the candidate’s quality. What you’re seeing in these elections really comes down to good candidates and bad candidates. A good candidate has real appeal, isn’t just smart, but can articulate their opinions persuasively to the American public. Nonetheless, I’m against assuming that one election result proves one ideological faction has, or will become, the future of the Democratic Party.
Do you think we are in a constitutional crisis?
This term usually describes a situation in which a sitting president directly defies a Supreme Court ruling.
VanSickle-Ward: Yes, we are absolutely in a constitutional crisis. Even more than Trump disobeying the courts, it’s evident in the courts’ inability to check the president. It’s not solely about whether the courts agree with Trump politically or ideologically, but also whether they are willing to exercise their constitutional role as an independent check on presidential power. Beyond that, Trump’s election denial and the Jan. 6 insurgency raised fundamental constitutional concerns, foreshadowing what would follow in his second term.
Professor Thomas: I’m not sure if crisis is the correct term; I think of it more as “a slow constitutional decay.” The issue goes beyond denying a certain ruling (which he also thinks is outrageous). The issues include presidential compliance with court orders, executive spending, due process, press access, and the erosion of political norms. What is happening now is bigger than periodic misbehavior; Trump is eroding every standard the public has understood for a president. When a political party used to care about constitutional questions and no longer does because it is beholden to Trump, you have a “constitutional rot, which is worse than a crisis you might get over.”
The distinction between the two professors’ responses to this question is notable. VanSickle-Ward focused heavily on the Constitution’s structure being undermined, while Thomas emphasized the gradual erosion of norms and whether Trump’s actions show other politicians that the principles we have upheld as a country don’t matter.
When we look back on the 2026 midterms five or 10 years from now, what do you think they will tell us about where American politics were headed at this particular moment?
It is hard to determine history from a singular outcome, something both professors mentioned.
VanSickle-Ward: Historians should first be curious about the actual voting patterns in the midterm elections. I am eager to learn whether voters can participate meaningfully, especially given Trump’s attacks on voting services such as mail-in ballots. I’m most interested in what happens to the Republican Party after Trump. “If Democrats do win, what is the Republicans’ response?” The Democratic Party has several candidates. The Republican Party is, you know, the party of Trump right now. The question is what happens when Trump can no longer be the Republican candidate; what happens when the figurehead has diminished? Will Republicans take his loss as a sign that the Trump model won’t work for them, or, if they win, will they take that as a push to create another figure who can reproduce the Trump vision?
Thomas: The consequences of the 2026 elections depend heavily on what happens after the election. Multiple outcomes are possible, some leading to Trump’s demise and others adding to his power and his will to execute it. The Democratic Party should not become overconfident or misrepresent what their victory means. I can also imagine a scenario where the Republican Party is like, good God, this guy is awful, and you actually start to see the Republicans move away from him. However, I can’t give a certain answer because politics has become increasingly unpredictable.
The 2026 midterm elections will determine the control of Congress, but their significance will extend beyond the immediate balance of power. They will show civilians where our country is heading, whether that is a place where constitutional rot continues or where Trump’s power finally gets checked. They will emphasize the importance or unimportance of individual candidates compared to fundamentals. The American public will see how both parties want to be defined and how Congress will exercise oversight in the two years left of Trump’s second term.
Discover more from Newsprint Magazine
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
